From Kanya Farm’s experience, we examine the economics, benefits and risks of organic and conventional agriculture, and ask whether the food we produce should be judged by the money it makes or the health it protects.
Imagine buying a kilogram of tomatoes at your local market. You probably consider the price, freshness and appearance. But have you ever wondered what went into producing them? How much fertiliser was applied? Which pesticides were used? Were the recommended waiting periods observed before harvesting?
These are questions most consumers rarely ask, yet they are central to one of agriculture’s biggest debates: organic farming versus conventional farming.
For years, organic agriculture has been promoted as a healthier and more environmentally responsible alternative to conventional farming. On the other hand, synthetic fertilisers and pesticides have helped farmers increase productivity, control pests and produce food at commercial scale.
Both approaches have advantages. Both have limitations. And both have economic consequences.
At Kanya Farm in Nanyuki, our journey towards developing a sustainable agricultural enterprise has brought us face to face with this debate. From sourcing animal manure and improving soil health to dealing with caterpillars and other crop challenges, we are discovering that producing food responsibly requires more than good intentions.
The bigger question is whether farmers can protect the environment, produce safe food and still make a sustainable profit.
1. Two farming systems, two different philosophies
Organic farming prioritises natural ecological processes, soil health and biodiversity. It relies on practices such as composting, animal manure, crop rotation, intercropping and biological pest management. It also restricts the use of synthetic fertilisers and many synthetic pesticides under recognised organic standards.
Conventional farming, meanwhile, generally permits synthetic fertilisers, herbicides, insecticides and fungicides alongside other agricultural practices to improve productivity and protect crops.
An important clarification: organic does not mean pesticide-free. Organic farmers can use approved biological and certain naturally derived pest-control products. Equally, conventional farming does not automatically mean excessive chemical use.
The real distinction is how production is managed and which inputs are permitted.
2. The case for organic farming: What happens beneath the soil?
One of the strongest arguments for organic agriculture is its emphasis on soil health.
Think of soil as the foundation of a house. You can keep repairing the walls, but if the foundation deteriorates, the entire structure becomes vulnerable.
Organic farming seeks to build that foundation through compost, animal manure, crop rotation, cover crops and the activity of beneficial soil organisms.
At Kanya Farm, we have been exploring this approach through soil testing, sourcing animal manure and developing a diversified farming system. Our intention is to build productive land that can support agricultural activities over the long term rather than simply maximise the next harvest.
There is scientific evidence supporting this approach.
A 2024 study published in the Journal of Agriculture and Food Research examined 15 years of comparative organic and conventional farming trials at Chuka and Kandara in Kenya’s Central Highlands.
The researchers found that maize and baby corn achieved relatively comparable yields under the two systems, with yield differences ranging from approximately 13 percent lower to 12 percent higher in organic production.
However, cabbage, French beans and potatoes experienced larger organic yield gaps, ranging from approximately 30 to 50 percent.
The researchers attributed these differences partly to nutrient limitations and increased pest and disease damage. They also found that better crop diversification, nutrient management and integrated pest control could narrow the gaps.
The finding is important: organic farming can work commercially, but success depends heavily on the crop and the farmer’s technical ability.
3. The uncomfortable reality: Organic farming is not necessarily cheaper
There is a tendency to romanticise organic farming, as though replacing synthetic fertiliser with animal manure automatically makes production cheaper.
Unfortunately, farming does not operate on good intentions.
Organic manure must be sourced, transported, stored and properly applied. Composting takes time, and nutrient availability can be less predictable than with concentrated synthetic fertilisers.
Pest management can also demand considerable labour and technical knowledge.
At Kanya Farm, our experience with caterpillars has demonstrated that avoiding conventional chemical interventions does not make pests disappear. They still attack crops, and the farmer must have an effective management strategy.
There is also the question of yield.
If one acre of conventional potatoes produces 17 tonnes while an organic system produces nine tonnes under otherwise comparable conditions, the organic farmer must find a way to compensate for that production difference through lower costs, better selling prices or other commercial advantages.
This is why organic farming should be evaluated as a business, not simply as an environmental preference.
4. Why conventional farming remains attractive
Synthetic fertilisers and pesticides have an important place in modern agriculture.
Synthetic fertilisers provide concentrated nutrients in relatively predictable quantities. Where soils are deficient, they can help crops access essential nutrients at the right stages of growth.
Pesticides can also protect crops against insects, weeds and diseases that might otherwise destroy an entire harvest.
For a commercial farmer growing onions, tomatoes or potatoes, losing a crop to an uncontrolled pest outbreak can mean losing several months of investment.
Conventional farming therefore offers advantages in productivity, input predictability and certain aspects of pest management.
But there is a price to pay when these inputs are misused.
Excessive fertiliser application can contribute to soil acidification, nutrient imbalances and water pollution. Improper pesticide use can expose farm workers and consumers to unnecessary risks.
The issue is not that every synthetic input is dangerous. It is that agricultural chemicals must be selected, applied and managed responsibly.
5. What does the food on our plates contain?
This is where the conversation becomes particularly important for consumers.
A July 2026 study commissioned by the Kenya Organic Agriculture Network and its partners examined 45 samples of tomatoes, kale, spinach and onions collected from selected markets in Nairobi and Nakuru.
The laboratory analysis detected pesticide residues in 35 samples, representing approximately 78 percent of the samples tested.
More concerning, 15 samples, representing approximately 33 percent of the total, exceeded the European Union’s Maximum Residue Limits for the pesticides assessed.
Interestingly, none of the onion samples exceeded the applicable limits. Tomatoes accounted for the largest share of non-compliant samples.
These findings raise important questions about pesticide application, farmer training and compliance with recommended pre-harvest intervals.
However, detectable pesticide residues do not automatically mean that food is unsafe. Maximum residue limits are regulatory benchmarks, and exceeding them warrants investigation and corrective action. The Ministry of Health also cautioned against interpreting the study as evidence of an immediate health threat.
The World Health Organization explains that pesticide toxicity depends on the chemical, quantity and route of exposure. Agricultural workers who handle pesticides are particularly vulnerable when proper protective measures are not followed.
This is why responsible application, protective equipment, proper storage and observance of pre-harvest intervals matter.
Organic farming can reduce reliance on many synthetic pesticides, but it should not be presented as an absolute guarantee of healthier food. Food safety depends on the entire production and handling process.
6. Can organic farming actually make more money?
Here is where things get interesting for agricultural investors.
A farmer is running a business. At the end of the season, the question is not simply whether the crop was organic or conventional. It is whether the revenue justified the investment.
A comparative farming study published by the Research Institute of Organic Agriculture (FiBL) in 2018, examining six years of trials in Chuka and Thika, found that organic systems had higher production costs in some cases because of additional labour requirements.
However, organic high-input maize and baby corn systems achieved higher profitability than their conventional counterparts where premium prices for organic produce were available in Nairobi.
The opposite was observed for organic potatoes and vegetables, where lower yields affected profitability.
This illustrates an important commercial reality: organic produce can command premium prices, but those premiums are not guaranteed, and consumers must be willing to pay them.
For Kanya Farm, this is a critical consideration. Our ambition is to build a commercially sustainable agricultural enterprise. Producing responsibly must go hand in hand with controlling costs, maintaining quality and establishing a market that values the produce.
An organic farm that consistently makes losses is not sustainable simply because its farming philosophy is admirable.
7. Is there a middle ground?
Perhaps the debate should not be about choosing one side blindly.
Integrated farming offers an interesting alternative. It combines practices such as crop rotation, composting, biological pest control and soil improvement with carefully selected agricultural inputs where necessary.
Integrated Pest Management, for example, encourages farmers to monitor pest populations, introduce biological controls, use resistant varieties and apply pesticides only when justified.
Instead of spraying crops routinely, the farmer first establishes whether intervention is necessary.
At Kanya Farm, our longer-term ambition is to build a diversified agricultural system that prioritises soil health, responsible resource management and sustainable production.
We believe that agriculture should preserve the resources that make food production possible. But we also recognise that every crop has different nutritional requirements, pest pressures and commercial realities.
The objective is to produce safe, quality food while maintaining a financially viable enterprise.
The final question: Profit over health, or health over profit?
Organic farming is not perfect. It can be expensive, labour-intensive and technically demanding. Conventional farming has helped increase agricultural productivity, but irresponsible use of synthetic inputs creates avoidable risks to people and the environment.
Kenyan research demonstrates that organic agriculture can achieve competitive yields under appropriate conditions, although the results vary considerably between crops.
For us at Kanya Farm, this conversation goes beyond choosing between manure and synthetic fertiliser.
We are building something we hope will serve generations. The land must remain productive, the business must make money and the food we produce must be worthy of the trust consumers place in us.
But it raises a question every farmer, investor and consumer should confront:
When the pursuit of higher profits comes at the potential expense of human health and the environment, where should we draw the line?
Should we always prioritise maximum production and profitability, or are there circumstances where accepting higher production costs is justified by healthier food and more sustainable agricultural practices?
And perhaps the most uncomfortable question of all:
If we know how to produce food more responsibly, but choose cheaper methods simply because they make us more money, what exactly are we farming for?
At Kanya Farm, we believe agriculture should do more than feed people and generate revenue. It should preserve the very resources that make food production possible.
Because the true measure of a successful farm should not only be how much money it generates, but also what it leaves behind for the people who consume its produce and the generations who will inherit its land.
Leave A Comment